Beauty

Well-being

Business

Self-employed: an increased risk of social downgrading, according to INSEE

freelance

According to the INSEE (National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies), social mobility works better for employees than for the self-employed. Micro-entrepreneurs appear to be the most vulnerable, while qualifications, gender, and family history weigh heavily on career paths.

In France, the self-employed are 40% less likely than employees to experience upward mobility. This is one of the findings of a large-scale INSEE study conducted in 2023-2024 among 35- to 59-year-olds in employment (or having worked), with at least one parent who had previously worked.

Unsurprisingly, the comparison favors employees. Thus, 53% of employees are upwardly mobile compared to their mothers, compared to only 42% of self-employed workers. For men, the gap is just as marked: 41% of employees are moving up the social ladder, compared to only 29% of self-employed workers.

Conversely, 32% of self-employed workers experience downward mobility, compared to 22% of employees. In other words, employment, despite its constraints, remains a more protective framework for securing an upward social trajectory.

Micro-entrepreneurs, the first to be affected

Behind the average self-employed worker, one category stands out as particularly vulnerable: micro-entrepreneurs. They represent 26% of self-employed workers, compared to 42% in companies and 26% in non-micro sole proprietorships. But their social trajectories are much more fragile: 44% of them experience downward mobility, nearly double the number of self-employed workers working within a company (26%).

The profile also differs by gender: micro-entrepreneurs are slightly more female (51% women), while companies remain very male-dominated (72% men). The figures confirm a gender divide. When parents were employees, men are 1,3 to 1,4 times more likely than women to become self-employed.

But this choice often comes at a high price: more of them than women experience downward mobility, especially when they work as small self-employed people without employees or family help (62%). Their daily lives? Construction tradespeople, shopkeepers, repairers, food service professionals, or service providers.

However, educational attainment remains a decisive factor. With a long-term higher education diploma (bac+3 or higher), the chances of upward mobility are multiplied by six compared to a simple baccalaureate. Interestingly, the less qualified you are, the more likely you are to become an employee, even if your parents were self-employed.

Independence that is passed down through the family

In short, the baccalaureate remains a symbolic barrier: below that, independence declines significantly. But this social mechanism does not erase the effect of family transmission. Independence is still strongly "inherited": sons of self-employed fathers are 2,3 times more likely to become self-employed than sons of employees, and daughters of self-employed mothers are 1,7 times more likely. When both parents are self-employed, the probability of switching to employment drops further.

Finally, trajectories also differ by origin. The descendants of immigrants are slightly more likely to experience upward mobility than non-immigrants. On the other hand, immigrants themselves see their prospects diminish: they are almost half as likely to advance socially.

READ ALSO: Phased retirement open to all from age 60 comes into effect

Facebook
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email
In the same category

We use cookies